刘铁光, 赵银雀. 2018: 体育赛事直播画面侵权案件法律适用的规范研究——基于新近案例的实证分析. 体育科学, 38(1): 90-95,97. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.201801012
    引用本文: 刘铁光, 赵银雀. 2018: 体育赛事直播画面侵权案件法律适用的规范研究——基于新近案例的实证分析. 体育科学, 38(1): 90-95,97. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.201801012
    LIU Tie-guang, ZHAO Yin-que. 2018: The Normalizing Research of Legal Application on the Infringement Cases of the Moving Images of Live Broadcast of Sports Events——Based on the Empirical Analysis of Recent Cases. China Sport Science, 38(1): 90-95,97. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.201801012
    Citation: LIU Tie-guang, ZHAO Yin-que. 2018: The Normalizing Research of Legal Application on the Infringement Cases of the Moving Images of Live Broadcast of Sports Events——Based on the Empirical Analysis of Recent Cases. China Sport Science, 38(1): 90-95,97. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.201801012

    体育赛事直播画面侵权案件法律适用的规范研究——基于新近案例的实证分析

    The Normalizing Research of Legal Application on the Infringement Cases of the Moving Images of Live Broadcast of Sports Events——Based on the Empirical Analysis of Recent Cases

    • 摘要: 新近体育赛事直播画面侵权案件的法律适用表明, 司法实践中对具有相同案件事实的体育赛事直播画面侵权案件适用不同的法律规则, 导致保护与否以及保护适用不同法律规则的不规范状态。其根本原因在于, 司法实践对体育赛事直播画面在现行法律体系中应该归属于何种权益的客体产生了不同的认识。通过对现行相关法律的规范解释可以发现, 体育赛事直播画面本身并不符合现行立法中相关绝对权客体的前提条件, 但体育赛事直播画面及其制作者分别属于反不正当竞争法应该保护的法益与主体, 应该适用《中华人民共和国反不正当竞争法》的一般条款予以保护, 以规范涉体育赛事直播画面侵权案件的法律适用, 实现法律适用的平等原则。

       

      Abstract: The legal application in the recent cases of the infringement about the moving images of live broadcast of sports events shows that, the legal application is a unnormalized state in which protected or not, protected in applying different rules of different legislations exist in the same facts of recent cases. The root cause of the unnormalized state lies in that, different viewpoints that the moving images of live broadcast of sports events should be attributed to the objects of the right and interests in the present laws have been made in judicial practice. Through the normative interpretation of the current relevant laws, we can find that the moving images of live broadcast of sports events does not meet the pre-conditions of the right objects in the present laws, however, the moving images of live broadcast of sports events and its producer respectively satisfy the pre-conditions of the legal interests and parties in the anti-unfair competition law. In order to realize the equal principle of legal application by unifying the legal application in the same facts of cases involved on the moving images of live broadcast of sports events, the moving images of live broadcast of sports events should be protected by applying the general provisions of the Anti-unfair Competition Law of China.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回