张连成, 刘洁, 吕嘉玉, 高淑青. 2023: 从重复原则视角审视体育科学实验设计中的样本量问题. 体育科学, 43(1): 90-97. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.202301010
    引用本文: 张连成, 刘洁, 吕嘉玉, 高淑青. 2023: 从重复原则视角审视体育科学实验设计中的样本量问题. 体育科学, 43(1): 90-97. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.202301010
    ZHANG Lian-cheng, LIU Jie, LU: Jia-yu, GAO Shu-qing. 2023: Examination of Sample Size in Experimental Designs of Sports Sciences Based on Replication Principle. China Sport Science, 43(1): 90-97. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.202301010
    Citation: ZHANG Lian-cheng, LIU Jie, LU: Jia-yu, GAO Shu-qing. 2023: Examination of Sample Size in Experimental Designs of Sports Sciences Based on Replication Principle. China Sport Science, 43(1): 90-97. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.202301010

    从重复原则视角审视体育科学实验设计中的样本量问题

    Examination of Sample Size in Experimental Designs of Sports Sciences Based on Replication Principle

    • 摘要: 重复原则是实验设计的基本原则之一,也是研究者控制实验受试者个体差异的常用手段。遵循重复原则可以降低实验误差,改善实验精度,提高研究的效度和研究的可重复性。体育科学领域实验研究中违背重复原则的问题主要包括:多因素实验设计中某种处理缺乏必要重复、重复测量代替重复实验以及混淆实验分析单位导致伪重复、没有科学估算样本量等,这严重影响了实验的严谨性,其实验结果的可重复性令人担忧。为提高体育科学实验研究的可重复性,研究者应该重视遵循重复原则,合理把握样本量。体育科学实验研究在遵循重复原则时需要注意4个问题:1)厘清实验处理的最小单元;2)确定实验分析单位,避免伪重复;3)确定最小重复次数;4)科学估算样本量,估算时除了要考虑α值、效果量和统计功效外,还需要考虑精度等因素。

       

      Abstract: Replication principle is one fundamental principle of experimental design, and it is also a common means for researchers to control the individual differences of experimental subjects. Following the replication principle can enablefewer experimental errors, higher experimental precision, higher research validity and replicability. Major problems that violate the replicationprinciple of experimental studiesin the field ofsports science are: lack of necessary replications of a certain treatment in a multi-factor experimental design, pseudoreplication caused byrepeated measuresrather than experiments, pseudoreplicationcaused by confusion of experimental analysis units, and no scientific estimation of sample size. These problemshave had a seriousimpacton experiment integrity and resulted in concerns over the reproducibility of experimental results. Researchers should attach importance tothe adherence to the replication principle and to a reasonable sample sizein order to increase the replicability of sports science experiments. In line with the replication principle, emphasis should be put on four issues in experimental studiesof sports sciences:1) Clarify the minimum unit of experimental treatment; 2) Determine the experimental analysis unit to avoid pseudoreplication;3) Determine the minimum amount of replications; 4) Perform sample sizeestimationsscientifically, consider precision and other factorsbesides α value, effect size and statistical power.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回