郜卫峰, 冯鑫, 顾大成. 2019: 同期耐力与力量训练对长跑运动员跑步经济性及耐力表现相关指标影响的Meta分析. 体育科学, 39(9): 68-81. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.201909008
    引用本文: 郜卫峰, 冯鑫, 顾大成. 2019: 同期耐力与力量训练对长跑运动员跑步经济性及耐力表现相关指标影响的Meta分析. 体育科学, 39(9): 68-81. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.201909008
    GAO Wei-feng, FENG Xin, GU Da-cheng. 2019: Effects of Concurrent Endurance and Strength Training on Running Economy and Endurance Performance Indices in Distance Runners:A Meta-analysis. China Sport Science, 39(9): 68-81. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.201909008
    Citation: GAO Wei-feng, FENG Xin, GU Da-cheng. 2019: Effects of Concurrent Endurance and Strength Training on Running Economy and Endurance Performance Indices in Distance Runners:A Meta-analysis. China Sport Science, 39(9): 68-81. DOI: 10.16469/j.css.201909008

    同期耐力与力量训练对长跑运动员跑步经济性及耐力表现相关指标影响的Meta分析

    Effects of Concurrent Endurance and Strength Training on Running Economy and Endurance Performance Indices in Distance Runners:A Meta-analysis

    • 摘要: 目的:采用Meta分析方法系统评价同期耐力与力量训练对长跑运动员跑步经济性(running economy,RE)及体重(body mass,BM)、最大摄氧量(maximal oxygen uptake,<img id="2" type="formula" href="images/TYKX201909008_00200.jpg" display="inline" placement="inline" src="Detail/GetImg?filename=images/TYKX201909008_00200.jpg&uid=WEEvREcwSlJHSldSdmVpM3VCWENoekZpVHQzeWdJMlBJK0FyZ01SWC9Iaz0=9A4hF_YAuvQ5obgVAqNKPCYcEjKensW4IQMovwHtwkF4VYPoHbKxJw!!" style="height: 22px;"> <alt></alt>O_2max)、场地跑计时跑成绩(time trial,TT)等耐力表现相关指标的影响,为长跑运动员的训练实践提供有力的证据支持。方法:截至2019年6月8日,于CNKI及Pubmed、Springer、Embase、Sportdiscuss、Science Direct数据库检索文献。制定文献纳入及排除标准,制作数据提取表格,由2名有经验的评价员独立完成文献的初筛、全文筛选以及数据提取工作。以PEDro量表评价文献质量。运用Revman 5.3和Stata 12.0软件分别进行异质性检验、数据合并、亚组分析、绘制森林图及敏感性分析、Meta回归分析,绘制漏斗图并进行发表偏倚评价。结果:15篇文献中的17份研究纳入本Meta分析,含无系统力量训练经历的一般及高水平长跑运动员276人。PEDro量表评分6分的研究10份,4~5分7份,总体方法学质量较高。同期训练对BM无显著性影响(P>0.05)。最大力量训练及包含最大力量训练的混合力量训练,与爆发力训练对BM的变化有着相似的效应(P>0.05)。同期训练对<img id="3" type="formula" href="images/TYKX201909008_00300.jpg" display="inline" placement="inline" src="Detail/GetImg?filename=images/TYKX201909008_00300.jpg&uid=WEEvREcwSlJHSldSdmVpM3VCWENoekZpVHQzeWdJMlBJK0FyZ01SWC9Iaz0=9A4hF_YAuvQ5obgVAqNKPCYcEjKensW4IQMovwHtwkF4VYPoHbKxJw!!" style="height: 22px;"> <alt></alt>O_2max无显著性影响(P>0.05),但较等量训练而言,增量训练可能会引起<img id="4" type="formula" href="images/TYKX201909008_00400.jpg" display="inline" placement="inline" src="Detail/GetImg?filename=images/TYKX201909008_00400.jpg&uid=WEEvREcwSlJHSldSdmVpM3VCWENoekZpVHQzeWdJMlBJK0FyZ01SWC9Iaz0=9A4hF_YAuvQ5obgVAqNKPCYcEjKensW4IQMovwHtwkF4VYPoHbKxJw!!" style="height: 22px;"> <alt></alt>O2max降低(P=0.08)。训练水平是造成同期训练对TT影响研究间异质性的因素,同期训练对高水平运动员TT的促进效应非常显著地高于一般水平运动员(SMD:高水平组-1.46-2.33,-0.60vs一般水平组0.29-0.19,0.76,P<0.01)。同期训练对RE的改善有中等程度,且具有非常显著性影响(SMD:-0.52-0.86,-0.18,P<0.01)。爆发力训练、最大力量训练以及包含以上2种形式的混合力量训练对RE的改善有相似的促进效果(P>0.05),但等量训练的效果优于增量训练(P<0.05)、训练周期9~12周优于6~8周(P<0.05)。频率2~3次/周的训练可能优于1次/周(P=0.05)。结论:同期耐力与力量训练能有效促进长跑运动员RE的改善,且不会增加BM,但RE的改善更易在高水平运动员中转化为成绩的进步;训练频率2~3次/周,持续9~12周的力量训练更有可能收到理想的效果;在不降低耐力训练量的情况下,额外加入力量训练,会减弱RE的改善效果,并有影响最大有氧能力发展的风险。

       

      Abstract: Objective:To evaluate the effects of concurrent endurance and strength training on running economy(RE) and endurance performance indices,such as body mass(BM),maximal oxygen uptake(<img id="6" type="formula" href="images/TYKX201909008_00600.jpg" display="inline" placement="inline" src="Detail/GetImg?filename=images/TYKX201909008_00600.jpg&uid=WEEvREcwSlJHSldSdmVpM3VCWENoekZpVHQzeWdJMlBJK0FyZ01SWC9Iaz0=9A4hF_YAuvQ5obgVAqNKPCYcEjKensW4IQMovwHtwkF4VYPoHbKxJw!!" style="height: 22px;"> <alt></alt>O_2max),time trial performance(TT)by using meta-analysis,and to provide strong evidences for training practice in long distance runners.Methods:A literature search was conducted by using the Pubmed,Springer,Embase,Sportdiscuss,Science Direct and CNKI databases. Two experienced reviewers were assigned to screen the articles and extract the data from included original studies independently. The PEDro scale was used to assess the methodological quality of the included studies. The heterogeneity,data combining,subgroup analyses,producing forest plot and sensitivity analyses,meta-regression,producing funnel plot,publication bias were assessed with Revman 5.3 and Stata 12.0,respectively. Results:17 studies in 15 articles were analyzed,a total of 276 well and highly trained runners who had no history of strength training were included. 10 studies were assessed to 6 points in PEDro quality scores,and 7 studies were ranged 4 to 5 points. The concurrent training had no significant effect on BM(P>0.05). Compared with power training,the heavy weight training and mixed strength training had a similar training effect on BM(P>0.05). The concurrent training had no effect on <img id="7" type="formula" href="images/TYKX201909008_00700.jpg" display="inline" placement="inline" src="Detail/GetImg?filename=images/TYKX201909008_00700.jpg&uid=WEEvREcwSlJHSldSdmVpM3VCWENoekZpVHQzeWdJMlBJK0FyZ01SWC9Iaz0=9A4hF_YAuvQ5obgVAqNKPCYcEjKensW4IQMovwHtwkF4VYPoHbKxJw!!" style="height: 22px;"> <alt></alt>O_2max,but the risk of deteriorating <img id="8" type="formula" href="images/TYKX201909008_00800.jpg" display="inline" placement="inline" src="Detail/GetImg?filename=images/TYKX201909008_00800.jpg&uid=WEEvREcwSlJHSldSdmVpM3VCWENoekZpVHQzeWdJMlBJK0FyZ01SWC9Iaz0=9A4hF_YAuvQ5obgVAqNKPCYcEjKensW4IQMovwHtwkF4VYPoHbKxJw!!" style="height: 22px;"> <alt></alt>O_2max could be higher in incremental volume training subgroup than that of equal volume training subgroup(P=0.08). Training level was considered to be a factor affecting the heterogeneity of the studies,the concurrent training was more effective for TT in highly trained runners than that of well-trained runners(SMD:highly trained subgroup-1.46-2.33,-0.60vs. well-trained subgroup 0.29-0.19,0.76,P<0.01). The concurrent training had a moderately and significantly beneficial effect on RE(SMD:-0.52-0.86,-0.18,P<0.01). The power training,heavy weight training and mixed strength training had a similar positive effect on RE(P>0.05),but the equal volume training was better than the incremental volume training(P<0.05),and the training duration of 9~12 weeks was better than 6~8 weeks(P<0.05). The training frequency of 2~3 times/week could be better than 1 time/week(P=0.05). Conclusions:The concurrent endurance and strength training could enhance RE in distance runners without BM gaining,and the improvement of RE could be more effective in improving exercise performance in highly trained runners. The training frequency of 2~3 times/week for 9~12 weeks could achieve an ideal training effect. The addition of strength training with a certain endurance training volume will attenuate the benefit effects on RE,and it will increase the risk of deteriorating the maximal aerobic capacity.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回